Emergency department screening more than doubles detection of syphilis cases

Providing optional syphilis tests to most people seeking care at a large emergency department led to a dramatic increase in syphilis screening and diagnosis, according to a National Institutes of Health (NIH)-supported study of nearly 300,000 emergency department encounters in Chicago.

Most people diagnosed had no symptoms, which suggests that symptom-based testing strategies alone could miss opportunities to diagnose and treat people with syphilis. The results were published today in the journal Open Forum Infectious Diseases. 

READ MORE: NIH awards will support innovation in syphilis diagnostics

READ MORE: More older adults being diagnosed with STIs such as gonorrhoea and syphilis

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that adult and congenital syphilis cases increased by 80% and 183% respectively between 2018 and 2022. Improved syphilis diagnosis strategies will be essential for reaching populations such as pregnant women and people with limited access to health care.

The optimal model for syphilis screening has not been identified, particularly for preventing congenital syphilis. Previous literature supports targeted emergency department syphilis screenings based on clinical factors such as active symptoms or pregnancy. However, the screening criteria used in those models would not capture most people whose syphilis is asymptomatic. 

Screening policy

In the current study, the team introduced a syphilis screening strategy that offered optional syphilis tests to anyone whose electronic health record indicated they were between the ages of 18 and 64 years, had no documented HIV diagnosis, and had not been screened for HIV within the past 12 months. Syphilis testing also could be ordered for anyone not meeting those criteria based on clinical decision making.

The study was conducted in a large, urban, academic emergency department in Chicago and assessed screening and diagnosis outcomes between June 2017 and May 2021—two years before the novel screening strategy intervention was introduced, and two years while it was in use—amassing a data set of 299,651 emergency department encounters.

Before the screening strategy intervention was introduced, only 5,209 of 146,644 (3.6%) people received syphilis tests. Post-intervention, testing increased dramatically to 37,289 of 153,007 or 24.4% of emergency department encounters. The number of people with presumed active syphilis infection based on the study testing algorithm increased from 161 to 624 post-intervention.

Few with symptoms

Only a small proportion of people with presumed active syphilis infection presented with symptoms or underwent sexually transmitted infection testing. Among pregnant women, the proportion of women screened increased from 272 of 4,579 (5.9%) pre-intervention to 2,061 of 4,129 (49.9%) post-intervention. Confirmed syphilis diagnoses among pregnant women increased from two cases pre-intervention to 15 post-intervention, while the positivity rate remained constant, suggesting many missed opportunities for diagnosis pre-intervention. The number of concurrent syphilis and HIV diagnoses increased from seven to 24 without any additional intervention specific to HIV testing.

The authors suggest that optional emergency department screening could help close current healthcare gaps in syphilis diagnosis and treatment, including among pregnant people, high incidence populations, and people with limited access to routine health care. The study was led by the University of Chicago Sections of Emergency Medicine and Infectious Diseases and Global Health, with funding from the NIH’s National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID).